In recent years, Idaho has become a popular destination for people looking to escape the high costs and fast-paced lifestyle of states like California. However, not everyone who made the move to Idaho has chosen to stay. In a video by real estate advisor Erica Toffel, host of the YouTube channel Living in Idaho, she explores the reasons why some individuals are deciding to leave Idaho and return to California or move elsewhere.
The Allure of Affordability
According to Toffel, one of the main reasons people initially moved to Idaho was the perception of affordability. The cost of living in Idaho, particularly in terms of utilities and everyday expenses, is indeed lower compared to California. However, many new arrivals are surprised to find that the gap in housing prices isn’t as wide as they expected. While Idaho’s housing market is cheaper, it is not the bargain it once was. The dream of purchasing acres of land with a large home for a relatively low price is no longer as attainable as it was 15 or 20 years ago. This affordability disconnect has led some individuals to reconsider their move and return to California or try their luck in other states like Texas or Tennessee.
The Job Market Dilemma
Toffel highlights the job market as another critical factor influencing people’s decision to leave Idaho. Some individuals move to Idaho without securing employment first and then struggle to find suitable jobs, either because they are overqualified or because the pay is lower than what they were accustomed to. Others who initially had the flexibility to work remotely faced challenges when their employers required them to return to the office, making commuting from Idaho impractical. This situation prompts people to seek job opportunities in cities with more robust job markets.
The Slow Pace of Life
Idaho’s slower pace of life, which some find appealing initially, can become a drawback for others. Toffel explains that while Idaho is known for its friendly and laid-back atmosphere, it may not satisfy those who crave constant social interaction, nightlife, or a wide range of cultural experiences. Although Idaho offers abundant outdoor activities, it may not provide the cultural or social adventures some individuals seek. As a result, people who find the pace too slow or the cultural offerings too limited may decide to move back to California or to other locations that better match their lifestyle preferences.
Political and Cultural Differences
Idaho’s political and cultural landscape can also be a factor in people’s decision to leave. According to Toffel, Idaho tends to be more conservative, which can be surprising for newcomers expecting a more progressive environment. While cities like Boise offer pockets of liberal policies, the overall conservative values of the state may not align with everyone’s beliefs. Those uncomfortable with Idaho’s political climate might choose to relocate to areas that better align with their values.
Family Expectations and Realities
Expectations around family dynamics play a significant role in relocation decisions. Toffel notes that some people move to Idaho with the hope that their family members will follow. However, when family members do not relocate as planned, especially elderly parents who may find moving difficult, it can lead to a change in plans. Families often return to where the majority of their relatives reside to provide support and maintain family connections.
Weather and Lifestyle Adjustments
Weather can be a deciding factor for those considering leaving Idaho. While Idaho offers beautiful spring, summer, and fall seasons, the winter months can be harsh and cold. This climate can be challenging for those accustomed to the milder weather in Southern California. The prospect of enduring long winters can prompt individuals to return to warmer climates.
Healthcare and Education Concerns
Toffel points out that healthcare and education are other areas where Idaho may fall short for some residents. While Idaho has good access to primary healthcare providers, it lacks the extensive options for specialized medical care found in larger cities. Similarly, Idaho’s education system is generally good, but it may not meet the specific needs or expectations of all families, particularly those seeking more diverse or competitive educational opportunities. Families seeking broader options for healthcare and education may choose to move to areas with more resources.
“Idaho Winters”
People in the comments shared their thoughts: “At least those folks have the good manners to leave and not spend their time trying to change ID into where they came from.”
One person added: “Another factor that needs to be emphasized is that Idaho winters are not California winters. Twice as cold and last nearly seven months. People visit Idaho durring the summer and fall in love with it not realizing that that same place in winter is a different planet.”
Another commenter concluded: “Housing isn’t cheap in Idaho because California folks cashed in on their California homes and paid cash for many homes in Idaho. Drove the prices thru the roof.”
Not the Right Fit
Erica Toffel emphasizes that while Idaho is an excellent place to live for many, it may not be the right fit for everyone. The slower pace, political climate, job market, and lifestyle differences can all influence the decision to move back to California or seek new opportunities elsewhere. Ultimately, understanding the nuances of life in Idaho before making the move is crucial to ensure that expectations align with reality.
Maintaining Unique Qualities
What are your thoughts? How can states like Idaho balance growth and development while maintaining the unique qualities that attract newcomers? What strategies can communities adopt to better support newcomers in integrating and adapting to local culture and lifestyle? In what ways can Idaho address the healthcare and education concerns that lead some residents to leave?
Watch the entire video on Living in Idaho’s YouTube channel for more information here.
